Wannabe Awesome Me
  • Viz 'Em
    • Tiny Tableau Tips
  • Mentor Match
    • Mentor Match Blog
  • A Pop of Color

Vizzing in Public

10/19/2016

1 Comment

 
Friends! It's been a minute since I wrote a thought piece on data viz and I had so many thoughts in my head that I had to get them down on paper. 

Today's topic is about vizzing in public. Sounds like a lewd act you might be arrested for. As an aside, I think we have more safety monitors than viz police. I'll come back to this in a bit. 

I've been talking Tableau with folks the last couple of weeks at the AARP TUG (oh hai, Brittne) and on Think Data Thursday (high five to my TDT partner in crime Ravi Mistry)! In both talks, I advocated for projects like Makeover Monday (MM), which I obviously dig. Ahem... Em, do you even MM?
Picture
Why yes, I do! I don't participate every week like others and I’m okay with that. The biggest reason why I love MM is because it’s a data set playground, waiting for me to have fun. I viz when I have time or when the topics interest me.
Because I don't use Tableau in my work life (except as an end user), I use MM to keep current with Tableau’s features. Other people use it for different things, like learning new approaches or skills, or to be creative. I’ve had #barchartburnout from work and I was oh so happy to have an outlet to do something more. And I hope that people respect that I can support MM without being all in with it (heck, I'm lucky if I can get an hour on Sundays to sit at the laptop).  

I believe we need to respect how we individually use Makeover Monday and the vizzes we post to our Tableau Public profiles or Twitter (or name your forum). I think a really good example of this is this recent viz from Rody Zakovich. He visualized a recent MM data set on the U.S. Presidential election. He had a dream about how he wanted it to look and set out to make it so.
Picture
How awesome is that?!?! Now, when I saw this viz, I found it hard to read. It is visually stunning and looks like something I'd see onlIne from a news organization, not some random dude’s tweets.

This viz generated a lot of discussion on Twitter (yay)! I added to the conversation that there is a challenge with looking at vizzes in a tweet or on someone’s Tableau Public profile because you might not have the context around the viz, their ideas, and their thought process. How are we to know they're for fun or for creativity or a way to demonstrate best practices or created to learn a new skill?

I've seen some MM vizzes that are beautiful and informative and best practices. I’ve seen some that are cool and fun and some that are just… well, exploding pie charts. 
Picture
That's where I apply some critical thinking skills. When I look at vizzes like Rody’s or an exploding pie chart, I don't think it's an example of what I should do. I take it at face value; Rody wanted to see if he could make his viz dreams come true. Maybe exploding pie chart person wanted to have a little fun too. 

When we post our work in public, we need to be prepared for folks to ask questions and make comments. I am concerned that, to some extent, a new person to data viz/Tableau sees all of these vizzes from MM (arguably the biggest Tableau/Public community project) and think these are examples of what they should do. Further, I think there's a bit of danger when Zen Masters publish these fun, creative pieces. As a Tableau Community we hold these folks in high regard. At the end of the day, they are not the end all, be all and they have their own objectives as well. 

Just because a Zen Master publishes a viz or makes a statement, that does not make it a viz law. I remember a time on the Tableau Wannabe Podcast when Andy Kriebel talked about left justifying titles. After that episode, I saw several tweets about how people needed to go back and fix their titles. That was Andy’s preference, not viz law. But when he (& other zens) speak, people listen. 

Let’s go back to critical thinking and education. I know good data viz practices, and when I look at a viz like Rody’s, I'm not looking at that as good/best/better data viz practice (which he acknowledged as well). Do I respect what he did? Absolutely. Others asked questions about how to read the viz. I think that's a valid question. That's what's great (even though a bit uncomfortable) about vizzing in public…you get questions, people engage, understand thought processes, and learn! 

Are people trying to be viz police? Generally I don't think so, but as with anything there's always folks out there who think they are.  I believe more than anything, they're safety monitors, who in this age of data, are trying to do their part to engage so other people can learn and then apply critical thinking skills. 

I suppose my point to this post is that we should respect what people do, educate ourselves (ask questions/engage in discussion), and apply critical thinking skills.

That's my perspective. Certainly I'm not the Viz Police Commissioner, and I hope you'll think about this commentary and consider how you engage, viz, and think about vizzing in public. If you’re going to #data16, you can attend MM Live and experience it for yourself. Click here for the details!
1 Comment
Chris Love link
10/20/2016 08:08:38 am

An interesting read, thanks for sharing; I wholly subscribe to what you have written. The biggest two themes here are respect - we need to respect what everyone uses Tableau Public for and also respect other's critique of our work - and communication - healthy discussion and debate is what makes this field and community interesting.

One point you haven't raised, which is important, is around the need for attention / publicity / engagement when vizzing publicly. That naturally takes us, as authors, away from best practice and towards techniques and visualisations that attract more attention (we're all looking for a "Wow" reaction aren't we?). It's natural that that happens on a public platform like Public but it's also natural the community checks and balances itself over time.

It's also important for newcomers to the field to understand that going for "Wow" isn't the only way to attract attention in the data visualisation world and the community needs to try hard to encourage and reward people who focus on best practice / understanding / insight (which on the whole I think they already do).

Personally I think the community is richer for people like Rody and others who test and retest the boundaries of what works and what doesn't with MakeoverMonday, I won't always agree with their output but I will always respect the process and the learnings we gain as a community from every viz.


Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Follow my blog with Bloglovin

    RSS Feed

    What's This About?

    After using Tableau in my last position, I'm now a data viz hobbyist and this is my little slice of world dedicated to data visualization...typically Tableau related. 

    Vizzed and Confused? 
    Here are some great resources!

    Anya A'Hearn 
    Andy Cotgreave 
    Kelly Martin
    Andy Kriebel
    Matt Francis
    Jonathan Drummey
    Jewel Loree
    Peter Gilks
    Paul Banoub
    Dan Murray
    Ramon Martinez
    Ben Jones
    Allan Walker

    Tweets about "#dataviz"
    Tweets about "@tableau"

    Archives

    May 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.